The artistry of “The Dropout” is that while it never makes excuses for Holmes and shines a harsh spotlight on her bizarre behavior and sociopathic-level lack of empathy, we see her as a three-dimensional human being who had unlimited potential and probably WOULD have achieved something great had she listened to those who were trying to get her to slow down and do things the right way.
External reception
External reviews
You get a sense of who Holmes was, what drove her ambition and, ultimately, the desperation behind her foolish delusion that she had to stay the course, even as things careened out of control. Yet the series never lionizes her or glorifies her actions—tempting given the scale and implausibility of what she pulled off for as long as she did. ... [The Dropout] gives us something much more valuable, something that Theranos hoped to achieve itself: A new, better way of doing things.
Start engraving a Best Actress Emmy for Amanda Seyfried who is sensational as Theranos founder and fraudster Elizabeth Holmes in a true-crime story that is more than compulsively watchable, it’s a cautionary fable that really stings.
"The Dropout" will be tough to top, or even match, because of the way Seyfried, along with Meriwether and her writers, marry the visible facets of Holmes' put-on with her skewed ethical paradigm. ... ["The Dropout" makes] a person appreciate the scope of crime – and, better still, the extraordinary pleasure of watching Seyfried and the rest of the actors recreate this case with genuine confidence.
The discovery that Elizabeth might not be the most interesting or important person on screen at all times is what makes The Dropout so watchable and so often startlingly moving.
Think, “The Social Network” if it were less clinical, more emotionally perceptive, and somehow even sometimes sympathetic towards its similarly strange, dissocial, and pathological protagonist. It’s also led by an outstanding performance by Amanda Seyfried.
Great cast, fine performances, consistently entertaining.
Hulu’s portrayal of her girlbossing too close to the sun is captivating through and through.
The Dropout slowly draws you in, because the stakes are so much higher and Holmes’s rise is enthralling.
It’s a maddening, gripping, and at times startlingly funny recreation of a story that would feel too absurd to be true if we didn’t already know otherwise.
她就还是一开始就入错行了!想辍学创业提高创业成功率和效率还是得搞计算机,生物医药门槛太高了……
非常drama的那种好看,阿曼达的表演也捕捉到了原型人物身上说不出的偏执和疯狂。拜登出场的一段可以说是非常直白的揶揄了😂。不过在精彩之外确实也提出了一些新的反思角度,伊丽莎白借玻璃天花板理论和女权推特话题营销自己借以获得支持,而当骗局被揭露之后,反而使得硅谷的玻璃天花板现象更严重了,大佬们借以支持女性创业实则只为了私人利益并在真相揭露后全身而退,而真正受伤的是那么多在大学里真情实感视她为偶像的学生吧。
她还是好看的 这个角色很适合她 不过这套路下来骗了这么多人这么多年 也是本事了 可惜没走正道
Horribly miscast … 选角时只是在好莱坞里挑了个眼睛最大的人么?Amanda的气质太fragile了,她不适合演一个自信的疯子,她只会瞪着眼睛不停地点头。
什么神人能把这么精彩的原材料做出这么无聊的剧。。。没头没尾,什么都没讲清,好像想说Sunny在manipulate Elizabeth,但是又没深挖Sunny的个性,有时候又好像是反过来,但是最后这个新男友一出来明显意思就是同情Elizabeth,讲得跟她没有一开始就骗人一样。。。一切都是那么意想不到,以至于看完很生气,好像看着别人拿冬虫夏草蘸大酱。Amanda根本就不像Holmes,她眼睛大得非常有攻击性因为脸很圆很小,Holmes是长脸,所以穿个高领毛衣就显得很沉稳很温和,是老白男喜欢的没有攻击性的长相,声音又更老成,投资者放心,Amanda适合那种烈焰红唇,我不信金主看到Amanda这个张扬的五官会把她当自己女儿那种乖乖女。好像还在筹划一个詹妮弗劳伦斯演Holmes的项目,她外形更合适
没有书和记录片好看(3.5),不过E6非常棒!Erica和Tyler才是真正的iron sisters!不仅仅是电视剧,她们在现实里也是这么勇敢!
本人看起来会更加装一点的样子,也深信自己可以改变世界
【辍学生$欲速则不达】聪颖是天生的,经验是需要积累的,成功是需要不断试错的。不只是有个梦想就行,你得有长远的规划能力、你得找到赏识你的伯乐、你得学会管理团队、你得学会游说融资、你还得有非常好的运气等等。事实上,你需要的远比想象的要多,成功的太早是因为你根本没有成功。
7.5,比想象好很多,赛妹已经很努力在模仿本尊了,有些戏份非常到位,但总得来说她过分漂亮(for a ceo,对,容貌歧视),且少了一点点本尊的神经质,纪录片在先,剧情版还是值得一看,个性,情感,商业价值观。
主角配角个个神经兮兮,厌倦了美剧这种异化式审美。女主如果真整天战战兢兢瑟瑟缩缩,能拿到投资才有鬼。
没有预期中的好,人物并不吸引人,中国的部分也很“刻奇”,女主跟印度大叔的关系太流俗了,就是姣婆遇着脂粉客啊,可是其实应该把印度大叔怎么蛊惑女主走上犯罪道路的心路历程拍得再细腻一点,而女主家庭里那些破事儿不用展开那么多……整体来说,这个剧的戏剧观太low了,跟《中国合伙人》有一拼,“我功成名就了就要把你们实验室买下冠我的姓”,那种low得不行的暴发户逻辑,无语子。食之无味弃之可惜,最近的美剧为啥老给人这种感觉???
别只看结果,看过程。
感觉这个剧和虚构安娜有同一个毛病,就是女主一被戳穿整个人就慌张到不行,前三集看下来其实创业并不顺利,但好奇后面怎么一通骚操作让03年创立的骗子公司能挺到16年。以女主的学历和家庭背景,如果脚踏实地不急功近利的话,也是大有可为的。
这部和虚构安娜,女性视角,不是只赞美成功的、道德的女性,更好关注这些有争议的女性,关注她们的成长过程,这样才能发现社会的问题。开始觉得Amanda表演有点夸张,后面渐渐越来越好了。女主其实是高效率反社会型人格,她不能体会普通人的情绪,所以她经常突然说出一些让人尴尬的话,她需要反复对镜子练习演讲……第三集是一个高光时刻。既然她自己不具有普通人的情感,她开始挪用别人的情绪到自己身上,她借用了苹果店员愧疚的表情和言辞,示弱哭诉,而她小女孩的一面还真的就能吃定董事会的老白男们。话说女主就是中国父母的理想型孩子,学霸,拼命工作,立志做乔布斯,年纪轻轻得到千万投资。如果没记错乔布斯在发布会好像也造假过。而且她这个思路,连蒙带骗,跟政府攀上关系绕过药监局,这不就挺那啥的吗?
One good drama better than three terrible horror movies, Amanda made it.
推荐这部新出的美剧 。只能说tech行业也太好圈钱了,动辄上亿的funding,只要你拥有天花乱坠的头衔,引人注目的story,买一个XX排行榜排名,就能打着make the world a better place 制造海市蜃楼。今天是名校辍学的天才,明天泡沫一破就是阶下囚。泡沫破的还是一部分 还有一部分坑完本来就贫穷的老百姓就直接卷钱跑路。就算是这样了,留学圈里还有一大堆做着比尔盖茨乔布斯梦天天参加创业会的年轻人。咋说呢,还是那句话,年轻人“不要总是想搞个大新闻!too young too naive” 科研也好,生活也好,没有捷径可言。Fake it始终是fake it, 真实才能make it.
前三集差强人意,阿曼达尽力了但是目前给人的感觉太神经质,还是个子小小的小女孩的样子。第一集的女教授果然是纪录片里唯一那个从一开始就认为这个计划不可行并且指出问题的人,啊这敏锐度。4集弃,阿曼达跟人说话点头也太频繁了吧,桑尼的气场明显比她强,没法带入原型了
8.0/10 单凭阿曼达这么努力说中文,这剧就值4星。但是烧钱祭奠先人不是真的烧真钱啊。。。
🤣女主努力说中文的样子真的好苏
也只有把她拍得这么charming那么情有可原才好让那帮投资人顾问看起来没那么蠢吧
lwl community
Community reviews
Your Review
Sign in to write reviews, reply to threads, and like content.